Critical Flaw Costs Lawyer Thousands

A critical flaw was discovered by a defending attorney after the plaintiff’s attorney had spent thousands of dollars bringing the case to discovery.

a. 25 yr old woman in third pregnancy with one living child; first pregnancy had a compromised outcome
b. Premature rupture of membranes at 34 weeks of pregnancy; stabilized and transferred to antepartum unit to wait for pregnancy to reach 36 weeks, a common practice at this time
c. Sudden onset of bleeding and pain at 35 ½ weeks; fetal monitoring shows fetal distress; to OR and baby delivered within 8 minutes of primary nurse entering patient’s room
d. Mother had significant blood loss but fully recovered; baby needed extensive resuscitation but died two days later
e. Claim was made against the primary physician, admitting physician, and primary care nurse. Basis of the claim was that the patient’s call for help was not answered for twenty minutes by primary care nurse. This was substantiated by the patient’s husband watching the clock on the wall of the room.

Two vital errors were made by the plaintiff’s attorney that could have been identified by a legal nurse consultant:

1. He did not ask the primary care nurse what her patient load was at the time of the incident. There had been layoffs on the unit at this time. The incident also occurred during a time of night when nurses commonly take a one hour break and patient loads can be heavy. On this night, the primary care nurse was caring for six triage patients, an early labour patient and two antepartum patients which she had told the nurse in charge was too heavy for patient safety. However, the primary care nurse was never obliged to give him this information during discovery.

2. He did not confirm the actual presence of a clock on the wall of the patient’s room for her husband to time the response time. This unfamiliarity with hospital layout and the custom of clocks on the walls of rooms in other parts of the maternity unit cost the plaintiff their claim against the primary care nurse and wasted the attorney’s resources in preparing the case as well as three hours in discovery with the primary care nurse.